The crime was a homicide. The victim, 30-year-old Christine
Jean Schultz, was shot in bed in her home in Milwaukee, Wisconsin,
on May 28, 1981, at approximately 2:00 a.m. Her two sons, Sean
and Shannon, were in bed across the hall. Sean got up to check
and made the first call to his mother's boyfriend, a cop named
Stuart Honeck.
Four police officers went to the scene, where Sean let them in.
Honeck was the first to see the victim. He moved her and saw
that she was not breathing.
The victim was reportedly found lying on her right side, facing
west, although crime scene photos showed her lying on her stomach.
She wore a yellow Adidas T-shirt and white panties. A
clothesline-type cord was tied around her hands, binding them in
front of her, and a blue bandana-type scarf was wrapped around her
head, gagging her mouth. The T-shirt was torn near the wound,
a bullet hole in her right shoulder.
Police cut the cord around the victim’s hands and wrapped her
body in plastic. They removed a brown hair from the calf of
her leg.
The medical examiner was called two hours later.
An ambulance was called three hours after the murder, and the
victim was transported to the police morgue.
There was no evidence of a break-in, and the doors had heavy-duty
locks, including a deadbolt. Her former husband, Elfred
Schultz, who was also a cop and soon became a suspect, was allowed
to search the home.
According to Sean, age 10, he woke up to the feeling of something
like a rope or covered wire tightening around his throat. A
large gloved hand moved over his face, covering his mouth, eyes, and
nose. The glove was dirty and tan-color. He struggled,
pulled at the cord around his neck, and screamed. He heard the
person, whom he took to be a man, utter a deep growling sound.
The intruder ran out and crossed the hall. Sean followed
Shannon, his 8 year-old-brother, into the hallway and saw a man in
his mother’s room. When the man ran out past them, Sean saw
the man taking the steps three and four at a time, his green army
jacket flapping. At the bottom, Sean noticed that he wore
low-cut black shoes, like police shoes. He thought the man
wore a ski mask, and described him as having a physical stature
similar to Stuart Honeck. He went to his mother, who was still
alive, and ripped open her shirt to fix the hole in her back. He
turned on the lights and used a washcloth to try to wipe off the
blood, then wrapped gauze around his hand to put pressure on the
wound. At 2:30 a.m., he called Honeck.
Shannon said he jumped out of bed when Sean screamed, saw a man,
and kicked at the intruder. He described a large white male
with reddish hair tied into a long pony-tail, wearing a green
jogging suit with yellow stripes running down the sleeve. The
man then ran from the room and crossed the hall, entering their
mother’s bedroom. He heard a woman’s voice say, “God,
please don’t do that.” Then came a sound like a
firecracker. He raced to his mother’s room and saw a man
standing over her bed. The man then ran past him and down the
steps.
Several things are wrong with this investigation, which later
targeted Lawrencia Bembenek, the young wife of Elfred Schultz
(despite the fact that nothing about her fit the boys'
descriptions). Because the victim had been Schultz's wife and
was dating another cop, the investigating officers appear to have
forgotten procedure. In fact, Honeck actually believed that
Schultz had killed Christine and as the investigation progressed,
there was suspicion of a cover-up - especially when Bembenek, who
was convicted of the crime, claimed that she'd been framed.
There's no doubt that evidence was handled badly and the scene was
not secured. That means that there was room for reasonable
doubt, no matter who got arrested.
So how should a crime scene get processed?
Crime Scene Procedure
|
911 dispatcher (AP) |
When a crime is initially discovered, a call goes out to
authorities - generally via 911. A dispatcher notifies patrol
units close by. Uniformed police arrive and decide whether
they need other personnel (homicide or arson unit, for example).
They note the time and write down any other pertinent observations,
but refrain from touching or moving anything. If the
perpetrator is present, the officer makes an arrest.
Otherwise, the officer secures and controls the scene.
Sometimes it's difficult to determine the extent of the scene.
It might be a single room in a building, but it could just as easily
be outside. In the case of a murder, the crime scene could
extend to other rooms where the killer left traces of his or her
presence, out into a hallway, and even into a neighborhood. If
someone was killed or raped in one place and then transported
elsewhere, the crime scene extends to the vehicle of transport and
to the other location. However, the most pertinent evidence is
likely to be close to the point where the crime took place.
In major crimes like a bombing or a homicide, detectives are
called in. Their job is to take over the investigation to
determine:
- Who did it?
- What happened?
- When did it happen?
- How did it happen?
- Did it happen here or was another crime scene involved?
- Who is the victim?
- Why was this crime committed?
- What evidence is there to help prove the motive and the crime?
Witnesses are detained and interviewed. Some are
transported to headquarters to make formal written statements.
The detectives then prepare to obtain whatever search warrants they
may need.
If there's a body, the coroner/medical examiner checks it to be
sure it's human (some are in bad condition), and decides whether
there is reason for an autopsy.
While that's going on, the criminalists—also called crime
scene, evidence or identification technicians---are hard at work
searching for evidence and collecting whatever they find. Let's take
a look at their equipment.
|