By Adam Geller

(AP) — Just as before, law enforcement appeared overeager and bumbling. Just as before, a hyperactive press went into overdrive, eager to pronounce guilt. And just as before, a nation of voyeurs proved only too ready to play pundit.

advertisement

It has been almost a decade since the murder of JonBenet Ramsey, but it has taken less than two weeks of fevered — and apparently pointless — speculation to show how little things have changed.

That seemed clear Monday when prosecutors in Boulder, Colo., abruptly dropped their case against John Mark Karr — a 41-year-old itinerant teacher who insisted he had strangled the 6-year-old beauty queen at her home on Dec. 26, 1996 — saying DNA tests failed to put him at the crime scene.

"Because no evidence has developed, other than his own repeated admissions ... the people would not be able to establish that Mr. Karr committed this crime despite his repeated insistence that he did," District Attorney Mary Lacy said in court papers.

The admission by prosecutors that they had the wrong man might have seemed shocking if this had been any other case. But in the context of the Ramsey case — an investigation beset from its earliest stages by gross misjudgments by investigators — it struck many observers as not only expected, but also grimly fitting.

"If there's a single mistake they haven't made, I'm not sure what it is," said Philip Jenkins, a professor of history at Pennsylvania State University who has written on both child molestation and serial murder. "It fits, but it makes the existing record worse."

The decision to drop the charges against Karr completes a 12-day arc that echoed many of the themes that have characterized the case, albeit on a more compressed, but no less bizarre scale. It was made all the more ironic because Karr's arrest earlier this month came as the nation appeared almost to have forgotten the case.

Any hope of that ended Aug. 16, when police in Thailand arrested Karr and brought him before reporters, where he professed his guilt, saying he had been with JonBenet at the time of her death.

Pressed, he would not, or could not, describe just what had happened. But there was enough about his persona — a creepy narrative that included Karr's flight from child pornography charges in California — to whip the media and the public into a frenzy.

"Solved!," The Daily News of New York proclaimed across its front page on the morning after Karr's arrest. Its competitor, The New York Post, described Karr as a "pasty-faced, peripatetic kiddie-porn collector."

Next Page

See Crime Library Feature Story on JonBenet Ramsey Case

JonBenet Ramsey / John Karr Full Coverage

See Discussion Forum

For more daily crime news